A BTW Tribunal (shudder). In spite of our fairly strict adherence to some things, I think BTW's would be among the first to reject such an event. That doesn't keep us from snarking about some folks though, and thoroughly discussing perceived transgressions.
Scott was a man of integrity. I think he would have accepted negative reactions with grace and done what in his opinion served the Craft best. Though I'm sure the divisiveness that came out of his books would have horrified him.
Yes. This. I have heard about "tribunals" and "appearances" and even "indictments". These were in the latter day trads, though. I never heard of one in the orthodox three. Makes me wonder, indeed, what the gentle Mssr. C would have said. (or actually IS saying, he may still be having some effect on the Craft at large). Integrity & grace? Yes. Horrified, yes, indeed. Working toward the betterment of the Craft, yes, indeed, indeed. One of the two gentlest men I met, Isaac was the other.